AI Made Simple

Free guide · Reviewing AI-assisted work before publishing

Publish-Ready Review Checklist

Use this checklist before an AI-assisted update, memo, email or announcement leaves your working draft.

1. Review prompt

Copyable template 1
Review the draft below. Do not rewrite it yet.

Return a table with:
- exact statement or section,
- issue,
- evidence or requirement involved,
- risk if unchanged,
- recommended correction.

Check specifically:
1. every figure, date, name and factual claim,
2. assumptions presented as facts,
3. whether the requested decision is clear,
4. whether an owner and deadline are named for each action,
5. whether the tone fits the audience,
6. whether anything important is missing,
7. whether the draft promises more than the evidence supports.

Use only the supplied sources. Mark anything you cannot verify as NEEDS HUMAN CHECK.

DRAFT
[PASTE DRAFT]

SOURCES OR FACTS
[PASTE VERIFIED SOURCES OR FACTS]

2. Figures and facts

  • □ Every number matches a current named source.
  • □ Percentages show the correct denominator.
  • □ Dates and time zones are explicit where they matter.
  • □ Names, titles, product terms and links are correct.
  • □ Estimates are labeled and their assumptions are visible.
  • □ Unknowns are not disguised with confident wording.

3. Decision and action

  • □ The reader can tell what decision or action is required.
  • □ The recommendation is separate from the supporting facts.
  • □ Each action has one owner.
  • □ Each time-sensitive action has a deadline.
  • □ Dependencies and approval points are visible.

4. Audience and tone

  • □ The opening gives the reader the context they need.
  • □ The level of detail fits the reader’s role.
  • □ The tone is direct without being abrupt.
  • □ Uncertainty is stated calmly and precisely.
  • □ The draft avoids hype, blame and unsupported certainty.

5. Privacy and permissions

  • □ The draft contains only information this audience may receive.
  • □ Customer, employee and confidential information is minimized.
  • □ Links and attachments use the right access settings.
  • □ Nothing will be sent or published until the final reviewer approves it.

6. Worked example

Fictional draft before review

Copyable template 1
The Northstar pilot was a huge success. Almost everyone completed the form, and it will save the team hundreds of hours. We should extend it. Team leads can handle the next steps soon.

Verified facts

Copyable template 2
- 18 employees were invited.
- 14 completed the form.
- 3 submissions needed follow-up because required fields were blank.
- Time saved has not been measured.
- The operations director will decide whether to extend the pilot.

Problems found

Draft wordingProblemCorrection
“huge success”Evaluation without defined criteriaState the observed completion and follow-up figures
“almost everyone”Vague and potentially misleadingUse 14 of 18
“save hundreds of hours”Unsupported outcomeRemove; time saved was not measured
“We should extend it”Recommendation lacks reason and durationRecommend a two-week extension to test completion quality
“Team leads … soon”No owner or deadlineName one owner and a review date

Reviewed version

Copyable template 3
Fourteen of 18 invited employees completed the Northstar onboarding form. Three submissions needed follow-up because required fields were blank. Time saved has not yet been measured.

Recommendation: extend the pilot for two weeks while the operations lead tests clearer required-field instructions. The operations director will decide by Thursday at 4:00 p.m. If approved, the operations lead will report completion and follow-up results at the November 14 review.

7. Final human read

Read the finished version in the same format and device the audience will use.

  • □ The subject line or title matches the content.
  • □ The first paragraph makes the purpose clear.
  • □ Tables, links and attachments work.
  • □ No placeholder text remains.
  • □ The final version, not an older draft, is attached or scheduled.
  • □ The accountable person approved it.

Approval line

Copyable template 1
Reviewed by:
Date:
Version:
Approved for: Internal use / Sending / Publishing
Open conditions:

The rule to keep: A polished draft is not publish-ready until its facts, decision, owner, deadline and audience all agree.