Decision Criteria Starter
Write down your last 10 decisions. Let AI draft the rules you use. Then check them.
Step 1 · Pick one repeat decision
Choose a call you make again and again. Examples: which vendors make the shortlist, which ideas go to your leadership team, which projects get funded next quarter, which candidates get a second interview.
Step 2 · Fill in your decision log
Write 3 lines for each of your last 10 decisions. Keep it short. Your reason is the part that matters.
| # | What came in | What I decided | Why |
|---|
| 1 | | | |
| 2 | | | |
| 3 | | | |
| 4 | | | |
| 5 | | | |
| 6 | | | |
| 7 | | | |
| 8 | | | |
| 9 | | | |
| 10 | | | |
Only include what you're allowed to share. Remove names and confidential numbers if you need to.
Step 3 · Paste this prompt
Paste your 10 decisions into the AI tool your company has approved, then add:
These are my past decisions. Write down the criteria I seem to use. Then score these 5 new options against them and show your reasoning.
Add your 5 new options below the prompt.
Worked example · fictional
A manager logs 10 software vendor decisions. Three of them read:
- "Vendor A proposal. Rejected. Implementation needed 6 months and we had 3."
- "Vendor B proposal. Shortlisted. Integrates with the finance system we already use."
- "Vendor C proposal. Rejected. Only one reference customer in our industry."
The AI drafts criteria like: implementation fits the deadline; works with existing systems; at least 2 reference customers in the industry. It then scores 5 new vendors and explains each score.
Step 4 · Correct the criteria
Read the criteria before you trust any score. For each one, ask:
- Is this really how I decide, or did it read too much into one example?
- Is anything missing that I always check but never wrote down?
- Is the order right? Which criterion would make me say no on its own?
Then tell it. "Criterion 3 is wrong. Reference customers matter less than security review. Rewrite the criteria and rescore."
Save the corrected list. That's your rule sheet.
Step 5 · When an agent can take the first pass
Let AI do the first pass only when:
- the criteria are written down and you've corrected them at least once;
- you can see its reasoning for every score;
- a person still makes the final call.
For the boundaries on what an agent may do on its own, use the Agent Interrupt Rules: https://aimadesimple.ca/agent-interrupt-rules/
A reminder
AI drafts the criteria from your examples. It can get them wrong. You review them, and you own the decision.